Reputation Management Guide

Download Our White Label Digital Marketing Guide!

Download this free ebook to learn how to grow your business online.

Discover the #1 way to boost your digital marketing agency’s revenue
Download Your eBook!

"*" indicates required fields


A Complete Reputation Management Guide For Your SEO Agency In 2023

Feb 21, 2023
16 min read

Reputation management is the process of managing, protecting, and maintaining the public’s perception of a brand, business, or person.

Online reputation management has become crucial to operating a successful SEO service in the digital era. As more customers use the internet to research and assess businesses before making a purchase, online reputation can make or break your company.

Search engine optimization (SEO) strategies, as well as social media engagement and content writing strategies, help create a positive reputation for businesses online.

Reputation management not only helps you build a positive image but also helps in dealing with the negative reviews and backlash. When negative reviews or complaints from consumers are addressed and dealt with within 5 minutes, people are more likely to be retained as loyal customers.

This also helps you to keep an eye out for the valuable feedback that is left by your audience or consumers, helping you gain useful insights into your service and customer experience.

These procedures help you avoid the need for crisis communication management.

In this guide, we will take a look at the strategies that are used by SEO agencies for reputation management.

Select a Niche for Your SEO Agency

A key step in positioning your SEO agency for success is choosing a market niche. You can concentrate your efforts on a particular audience and stand out in a competitive market by selecting a niche that matches your firm and selecting particular SEO services to target.

Increased knowledge and a clearer target market are just two advantages of specializing in a particular sector or kind of service. For example, a legal services-focused SEO business may be more knowledgeable about the precise keywords and marketing techniques that will appeal to law firms and legal professionals.

The specific SEO issues that online businesses encounter may also be better understood by an agency that specializes in e-commerce. Numerous profitable specialty SEO firms exist, such as those that concentrate on local SEO for small businesses or those who are experts in technical SEO and website migrations. You can position your agency for long-term success and growth by carefully selecting your niche and identifying the best audience to focus on.

Establish yourself as an SEO expert.

One of the best ways to position yourself as an SEO expert is by sharing your knowledge through social media, blogs, and articles. This helps you build your personal brand and establishes you as a credible source of information.

Speaking at and attending industry conferences and events allows you to share your knowledge with a wider audience and enables you to network with other professionals in the field.

Search engine algorithms and consumer behavior are always evolving, so it is important to keep yourself updated and informed about all the latest changes in the industry. This can be achieved by reading industry-related blogs and participating in online forums and communities.

Deliver exceptional service to your clients.

High-quality service not only helps retain existing clients but also attracts new ones through positive word-of-mouth. To deliver exceptional service, it is important to understand your clients’ needs and goals and to consistently exceed their expectations.

One way to exceed client expectations is by providing prompt and personalized communication. Responding to emails and phone calls in a timely manner and addressing any concerns or questions they may have shows that you value their business and are invested in their success.

Another way to exceed expectations is by going above and beyond in your service delivery. This can be done by offering additional resources or support without any added cost.

Also, it’s critical to be proactive in spotting and resolving possible difficulties before your clients notice them. This demonstrates your awareness of their needs and your dedication to ensuring their satisfaction. Additionally, you must be receptive to criticism and prepared to change your offerings in order to better serve your customers.

Schedule A Consultation Now

Build a strong reputation among your clients.

Building a strong reputation among your clients is a long and time-consuming process. Some effective strategies and practices that help businesses achieve that goal include

Delivering quality work and results

Delivering high-quality work and outcomes that match or exceed clients’ expectations is one way to build a solid reputation. A happy client will always think and talk positively about you.

High-quality work and results help you increase the chances of positive mentions online, which are beneficial to building your online presence.

Providing excellent customer service

customer service

This includes being responsive to client needs, addressing concerns in a timely manner, and going above and beyond to ensure client satisfaction.

Customer service includes actively listening and acknowledging the needs of your customers. It means treating customers as a priority and thereby maintaining your online image.

Reviews, feedback, and comments must be addressed and responded to quickly, making sure that issues are dealt with effectively. Excellent customer service helps convey the message that their opinion matters to your business and that you acknowledge and appreciate support from your customers.

Building relationships

Building relationships with clients, white label digital marketing agencies, and other industry professionals can also help to establish trust and credibility in the industry.

When you partner or associate with known and established industry professionals, you earn the trust of your audience. This also helps you reach a wider audience and get high-quality backlinks.

Staying up-to-date

The market is always evolving; that’s why it’s important to continuously educate yourself to ensure that you are providing the latest and most effective strategies. You must keep an eye on all of the trends and tools in the industry to help you perform better.

One must be aware of the changing algorithms and form strategies based on them. It is important to keep evolving and adapting to deliver the best possible results for your clients and customers.

Fostering Strong Connections with Clients

Fostering strong connections with clients is one of the best ways to gain a powerful reputation online and offline as well. Having a strong connection with your clients ensures that they become your long-term, loyal clients, which is a big win in today’s increasing competition.

Some things that can help you win your clients over include the following.

  • Regular two-way communication ensures that you and your clients are on the same page.
  • Being transparent in your work processes builds trust with clients and reduces the chances of misunderstandings and miscommunication.
  • Always being open to feedback is a great quality that helps clients trust you.
  • Addressing issues and acknowledging mistakes, if any and actively correcting them with sincerity can have an ultimately positive impact.
  • Appreciating the feedback, comments and reviews by clients and responding to them in a timely manner makes clients feel more valued.

Schedule A Consultation Now

Build a strong online presence through SEO.

The most effective way to build a strong online presence is through SEO, as search engines like Google, Bing, etc., are widely used and trusted platforms.
SEO practices help brands rank higher on search engines. This builds a strong and trusted online presence, as the audience gets to see your valuable content quickly on the related keywords.

Begin with Extensive Keyword Research

Keywords are truly important when it comes to SEO practices. The searchability and improved SEO rankings of your content depend solely on the keywords you use in your content.

Any good SEO process starts with extensive keyword research and finding the perfect niche keywords for a brand to target and rank on.

It’s important to start with extensive keyword research to identify the terms and phrases that people are searching for when looking for products or services like yours or those of your clients. Targeting the related and popular keywords is the first step to gaining a strong online presence.

You can use tools like Google Trends or Ubersuggest to get the niche keywords that you should target. This will help you get the most out of your SEO practices in the competitive market.

Focus on Local Searches

A lot of brands tend to overlook local SEO opportunities, but the location-specific presence plays an important role in improving ORM. Creating location-specific, public listings with GoogleMyBusiness can help your business reach people in your area. Focusing on local searches helps you generate awareness in your area and ensure that you are known for your services. This also helps you increase conversion rates, capture public reviews and strengthen the SEO profile of your brand.

Only include authoritative backlinks.

There are many ways to build backlinks for a website, but it’s important to ensure that you only include authoritative backlinks on your website. For reputation management, rather than using spammy backlinks, you should look for authoritative backlinks from your partner brands.

The higher the quality of your backlinks, the better chances you have to rank higher in search results. You should make sure that you only use high-quality backlinks on your website, as low-quality, spammy backlinks can harm your reputation online.

Avoid over-optimization of keywords.

While SEO is about optimizing your keywords, over-optimization can be harmful to your brand. Over-optimization can have a negative impact on your content and should be avoided.

The content available on your site should have a natural feel to it. If your content is stuffed with keywords, it will appear forced, and search engine algorithms consider it an attempt to manipulate the search engine and might flag such your content. Keyword stuffing is treated as content spam by Google, resulting in negative rankings and a low online reputation.

Maintain quick page load times

People are more likely to leave the page if the load time is slow. This harms your online presence as the bounce-back rate increases, resulting in a negative impact on the audience.

Pages that load quickly are crucial for SEO. The seamless loading of pages is important for SEO rankings and better user experience. It is important to maintain quick page load times as this increases user satisfaction and the likelihood a user will stay on your site.

Utilize social media platforms

Social media platforms are part of our day-to-day lives. A strong, active social media presence is beneficial for building an online reputation and communicating with your audience.

Social media also has a significant impact on SEO rankings, and it should be used as an effective tool to build an online presence as well as engaging with your audience on a frequent basis.

Ignoring social media platforms could be the biggest mistake you can make while building your online reputation, as they have a lot of potential to elevate your online presence and build your image.


Constantly evaluate SEO performance

Constant evaluation of SEO performance is necessary as search engine algorithms keep changing. SEO isn’t something that you can just do once; it’s an ongoing process. You need to keep tabs on your SEO campaigns and monitor your insights. Regular updates to your strategies are also necessary because of constant updates and fierce competition. So, your efforts must be maintained and improved regularly.

There are various tools that could be of great help while monitoring SEO; for e.g., Semrush, Google search console, Moz, and more.


Managing your agency’s reputation

1. Audit your Online Reputation

An extensive audit of your online reputation includes reviewing your website, social media profiles, blogs and third-party business profiles. This helps you know how your audience views and talks about you online. It will give you an idea of what your strengths are and what challenges you might face while improving certain aspects of your business.

The basic method to start your audit is performing the task through Google:

  1. Open an Incognito window on your Google browser.
  2. Run a search for your brand name.
  3. Review your brand’s Google Business profile. Check any and all ratings, comments, reviews, images, etc.)
  4. Note the sites that appear on page one of the Google search.
  5. Divide the sites into two sections- one’s which you cannot control (i.e., third-party sites) and which you can control (i.e., social profiles)

This analysis will give you a rough look at how your audience views you online. If you want to research and gain more insight into your current position, there are various tools that are available, like SemRush’s Media Monitoring app, Mentionlytics, Hootsuite, etc.

Once you have gathered enough data, you can plan for your ORM.

2. Establish an online reputation management strategy

This should include ORM prioritization, policy documentation, communication guidelines, and tone of voice.

ORM Prioritization

When you have enough data and tasks that need to be done, it is important to prioritize them to get them done effectively. You can categorize your tasks according to the Impact Effort Matrix as discussed below to manage your tasks:

Easy wins: This category consists of tasks that have a high impact on the audience and are easy to accomplish.

Big Projects: This category consists of tasks with a high impact on the audience but take more effort to accomplish.

Fillers: This category consists of tasks that are easy to accomplish but have a low impact on the audience.

Thankless jobs: This category consists of tasks that take more effort to accomplish and have a low impact on the audience.

When you have your goals and tasks prioritized, you can develop clear documentation to keep things organized.

Policy documentation, Communication Guidelines and Tone of Voice

Policy Documentation:

Policy documentation outlines who is in charge of which channel, with their roles and responsibilities explained clearly if multiple people are working on the same channel.

It also includes making response templates to frequently asked questions and a guide to how you will respond to negative feedback.

Communication Guidelines:

Communication guidelines help you ensure that your responses are consistent and professional. It helps you prioritize your work as urgent and non-urgent, based on where your audience is most active.

Reviews, comments, and testimonials on platforms with wider reach and audience should be prioritized. Come up with an acceptable time frame to respond to non-urgent communication as well, so you can make sure that every customer is acknowledged fairly.

Tone of Voice:

Tone of voice should reflect your agency’s brand and values. Establishing a tone of voice depends on who your target audience is and what they prefer.

Your tone of voice guidelines need to be shared with anyone who communicates with the audience or creates content. This helps create a “persona” and helps your brand seem more unified.

3. Encourage Your Customers to Leave a Review

Encouraging your customers to leave honest, positive reviews online is one of the best ways to manage your online presence. This not only helps you increase your visibility but also your reputation.

There are a few ways you can encourage your customers to leave reviews on Google or other review sites.

  • Ask for reviews via email
  • Share links to leave reviews at the end of chat interactions on your site
  • Offer incentives like discounts to customers who leave a review
  • Respond to all reviews; it will show your audience that their opinion matters
  • Encourage customers to contact you directly for negative feedback to discourage them from writing negative reviews

While Positive reviews can make an online presence, negative reviews can break your image easily; that’s why it is crucial to respond to these negative reviews. A few things should be kept in mind while responding to negative reviews.


  • The earlier the issue is addressed is better.
  • Be polite when addressing the concern and show courtesy.
  • Acknowledge your team’s mistakes, if any, and try to resolve the issue by offering a refund or discount and making improvements to your product.
  • Try keeping the conversation open and public. This helps your audience understand that you are responsive and attentive to their opinions.

4. Monitor your online presence and mentions

Monitoring your online presence and mentions is also important to stay informed about what people are saying about your agency. This helps you know the opinions of your target audience and provides a base to plan ahead. One of the best ways to monitor your brand is by setting up a Google alert for your brand name. By doing this, you will receive an email whenever new results for a chosen topic show up in Google search. You should also search through other sites, platforms and forums manually on a regular basis, which can be a hassle. However, using media monitoring tools like Hootsuite, Mentionlytics or the media monitoring app by Semrush can help you get a clear picture from other platforms. These tools automatically collect the data related to people’s interactions with your brand on the web and provide the insights you need to assess the state of your online presence.


SEO and online reputation management are not one-time tasks but an ongoing process that requires regular maintenance and improvement to stay relevant and effective.

It’s important to keep monitoring your brand and staying engaged with your audience on a regular basis to create a positive impression.

SEO is a necessary step in reputation management and must not be taken lightly. The above-mentioned strategies should be followed by businesses to improve their online reputation and stay ahead of the competition.

Download Our White Label Digital Marketing Guide!

Download this free ebook to learn how to grow your business online.

Kshitij Chaudhary